A tired sofa or a set of worn dining chairs raises the same question: do you reupholster, or replace? The short answer is that it's usually worth it for a well-built piece, and not worth it for a cheap or badly damaged one. Here's how to tell which you have.
Start with the frame
The fabric is the easy part to change. The frame is what you're really keeping, so it's the first thing to check:
- Press firmly on the corners. A sound frame doesn't flex or creak.
- Look at what it's made of. Solid hardwood, such as oak, maple or ash, is worth saving. A plywood frame usually isn't. Good springs, such as hand-tied coils, are a sign of quality construction.
- A frame that has already failed is a warning sign. If it's weak or broken, the repair can cost more than the piece is worth.
An upholsterer can inspect the piece and tell you whether the frame is worth the work.
When reupholstering is worth it
- The frame is solid and the piece is well built.
- It has sentimental value, or it's an antique or family piece you couldn't easily replace.
- You like the shape and size and just want a new look or a more durable fabric.
When buying new makes more sense
- The piece was inexpensive to begin with, and the bill for labour and fabric would come close to a new one.
- The frame is weak, damaged or poorly made.
- You'd rather have a different shape or size, which reupholstering can't change.
Get quotes before you decide
Prices vary a lot by piece, location and upholsterer, so we won't guess at numbers. Get a written quote from a local upholsterer, then compare it with a new piece of similar quality, not a cheaper step down. Damage often only shows once the old fabric comes off, so it's wise to leave some room in your budget.
Simple pieces can be a DIY job
Drop-in dining chair seats are among the easiest pieces to recover yourself. Complex, valuable or antique pieces are best left to a professional. We sell fabric, not upholstery services, so we can't do the work for you, but we can help you choose the fabric and plan the yardage. For dining chairs, our guide to how much fabric you need is a good place to start, and the yardage guide covers other pieces.
Choose the fabric for the second life
A new cover is a chance to pick fabric that will last. Check the double rub count on the product page, where higher means tougher. Our FAQ suggests 15,000 or more for everyday home seating, and our guide to double rub counts explains it. Check the cleaning code too, and read the fabric care guide to see what each one means. Browse fabric for sofas and armchairs or fabric for dining chairs.
Order a 9x9" swatch first. Swatches are $10 each, with a flat $15 shipping anywhere in Canada, and all cut fabric is final sale, so it's worth seeing and feeling the fabric before you order.
